Wednesday, October 28, 2009

The difficulty in peddling an inferior product

A news item today talks about efforts by Christian evangelists to boost their witnessing in such New England states as Vermont, New Hampshire, Maine and Massachusetts, an area of the country that has become even more secular than the Pacific Northwest. Reportedly, up to 22% of New England residents claim no religious faith of any kind. This is absolutely wonderful news of a trend that I hope continues to spread. But it's sad faces all around for the poor folks at places like Redeemer Fellowship Church.

Several Christian denominations see New England as a "mission field" — a term often associated with unchurched, foreign lands. As they evangelize and work to plant new churches, they speak of possibility, but also frustration. The area's highly educated population is skeptical and often indifferent to their faith.

"About once every hour, I give up. It's tough, man," said a half-joking Joe Souza, a Southern Baptist missionary working north of Boston. "It's like, you found a cure for cancer and you want to give it away and nobody wants it."

That last remark illustrates with blazing clarity why fellows like Souza do not understand their difficulty in winning converts. Read the preceding sentence, Joe, where the people whom you are trying to reach are described as "highly educated" and "skeptical." There's your problem. You are dealing with people who are sufficiently intelligent to realize, much moreso than you, that you emphatically do not have anything to offer that can be remotely likened to a cure for cancer. (For one thing, if Souza's religion really were both true and as good as a cure for cancer, then there would be a cure for cancer. All powerful magic sky deity, remember?)

No, Christianity is in fact peddling an inferior product, one that offers the empty solace of "faith" in response to real-world problems, and then, with staggering arrogance, turns around and threatens people with eternal torture for non-compliance. Maybe there's a placebo effect in Christianity that can, I suppose, be argued to have better benefit than no effect at all. But "it's better than nothing" is not exactly what you'd call a ringing endorsement for a belief system that treats the human intellect as if it's something that can be won over with carrot (Heaven) and stick (Hell) theology.

The work is slow and its fruits can be scarce. Souza said people are generally polite, even interested in talking about spiritual matters. But they don't hesitate to reject invitations. He recalled a man with whom he recently shared his faith at the mall courteously declining to even take a card.

Of course. This man realized that Souza had nothing to offer that he wanted or needed. This is always how people respond to empty sales pitches: with indifference. Oh, it's a telemarketer offering me a limited-time-only deal on subscriptions to magazines I don't even read in the first place? Gee, why am I not clamoring to take advantage of that? Golly, it's a smiling but empty-headed buffoon in the food court telling me all about how much his invisible friend loves me? Sure, great, whatever — can you pass the sugar?

This trend, I think, is a terrific riposte to claims that those who criticize the "New Atheists" often make: that we may as well accommodate religion, because it is such a thoroughly ingrained part of our cultural landscape that we'll never be rid of it. Clearly, as the increasingly educated and skeptical population of New England are demonstrating, that is untrue. It doesn't take much to divest yourself of inferior products in your life. You just need to become a smart shopper.


  1. I can't the believe the arrogance of these people. No seriously, I can't. I'm a non-believer...of most things, apparently.

  2. "It's like, you found a cure for cancer and you want to give it away and nobody wants it."
    I facepalmed and said "that's because they've already got it!"

  3. I live in New England and I think this trend is almost certainly one of identification rather than underlying realities.

    This was a highly Catholic area and also one of the focal points of the priestly pedophilia scandal. Our local Cardinal, Bernard Law, was actually kicked upstairs as a result.

    I think a lot of educated cultural Catholics who didn't really believe any of the nonsense got disgusted and embarrassed enough to not identify themselves as Catholic anymore.

    Also if you're obviously from outside and obviously selling something with an obvious agenda, chances are we don't want it. We're not the friendliest of people until you've been here a few generations.

  4. The mission thing is strange. I am stereotyping, but, don't most missionaries go to third world countries, hand out food, build churches so that children can go indoors, and generally bring 19th century luxuries to areas that would consider that an improvement?

    Of course they're having problems now. the target is not "down on their luck". They aren't recovering addicts hoping for someone to fix their problems. And they certainly aren't hungry enough to sit through a sermon in exchange for a soft drink and prepackaged food.

    So, now the "missionaries" have nothing to offer, except for their ideas...And they find their target audience to have no shortage of that either.

  5. I like this article because it highlights the idea that being intelligent and skeptical are almost always indicators that someone won't buy into religion.

    Stories like this will eat away at the defense that theists use to try to act like they are being "looked down upon" because intelligence level by and large(yeah, I said it) does match up with non-belief.

    Great post Martin.


  6. Makes me want to move to New England. There's no such problem down here in good ole Jesusland (Texas).

  7. While I have never personally been preached to on the street, I always enjoy people handing out the flyers to passers-by. It's always amusing, either because the message itself is amusing or because it's amusing for me to just tear it up and throw it away the second they hand it to me.

  8. Having just relocated to Texas from Maine, I can see what a culture shock it must be for a bible banger to be selling his shoddy wares. Boston has the Irish Catholics but up north it is the French. It's not the custom for most people to be that vocal about what they believe. Churches for sure but no roadside mega-crosses and not so much on the radio. There is not much trust of "Flat-Landers" with something to sell.

  9. Gotta love it!

    This comic representation of the news article says it best.

    Converts in New England


PLEASE NOTE: The Atheist Experience has moved to a new location, and this blog is now closed to comments. To participate in future discussions, please visit

This blog encourages believers who disagree with us to comment. However, anonymous comments are disallowed to weed out cowardly flamers who hide behind anonymity. Commenters will only be banned when they've demonstrated they're nothing more than trolls whose behavior is intentionally offensive to the blog's readership.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.