Wednesday, January 23, 2008

American Idol beats up defenseless Christian virgin!

Over at Christian website, they're all in a kerfuffle over how mean the judges and host of American Idol were to poor Bruce Dickson, a 19-year-old from Bastrop (about half an hour from here) who, when asked to tell something about himself, admitted that he had never even kissed a girl.

"What?" Randy Jackson asked. "On purpose?"

"On purpose," Dickson said. "On my wedding day, that will be my first kiss."

Jackson's advice to Dickson after the judges sent him packing: "Go kiss some girls."

Simon Cowell, eyebrows raised, told him: "Avoid Ryan (Seacrest) on the way out."

Seacrest himself ended the segment featuring Dickson with these words: "Maybe next year he'll come back less a boy and more a man."

Dickson, of course, didn't take the ribbing well and went into full persecution mode.

"I respect women and don't think of them as a sexual object, and I'm the freak?" Dickson said.

Dude, fer fuck's sake! There's such a thing as being a sleazebag who sexually objectifies women...and then there's kissing a girl, something that is widely done by most heterosexual males at some point in their developmental cycle, and is not only not considered disrespectful (unless you're forcing it upon an unwilling kissee) but entirely healthy, normal, and — you'd better sit down for this — fun to boot!

I cannot help but notice that there's a big distinction to be made between the idea — perfectly sensible and sane — that you are the master of your own body and it's up to you what happens to it, especially sexually, and the way in which Christianity reframes and sells this message, heaped with great globs of guilt and fear-mongering designed to make young people think the proper way to confront their budding sexuality is to consider it "sinful," and suppress it until the magical day of your wedding, at which point everything bad about your body becomes good and holy and you can touch your pee-pee without fear of a lightning bolt up the back door.

There's a healthy way to promote abstinence, and it's not the way it's promoted in Christianity. Rather, what Christianity sells are some bitterly unrealistic expectations of marriage. I mean, what do Christians think they're protecting here? Do Christians really believe that if they remain virginal — and not just virginal, but refrain from any physical contact with the opposite sex at all — until holy matrimony, that this will have some kind of talismanic effect upon their marriages, rendering them perfect and idyllic in every way? No arguments, no financial strain, 100% contentment and happiness, and angelic obedient children? Well, it wouldn't be the first foolish thing Christians have chosen to believe, I suppose.

If you're looking for reasons why the divorce rate among Christians is so much higher — especially among Bible Belt Baptists — than any other demographic group, you might look to these "sexual purity" programs. These aren't about giving young people healthy, sex-positive messages that incorporate abstinence at all. It's about plugging this concept of "purity," which comes, naturally, with the inevitable view that failure to live up to purity's criteria means that you are impure and probably in danger of hellfire and damnation. Attaching the baggage of sin to sex is a recipe for some pretty debilitating neuroses.

Of course, a Christian reading this would offer the obvious false dilemma as a retort: "So what, I should just go out and have sex with everyone I see?" No, just be aware that your sexuality is part of you, and a good part of you, not something the Devil scotch-taped to your crotch in order to lure you into a fall from grace. Realize that part of acknowledging and growing in your sexuality means that it's something you control. The choice to take command of your body and not engage in sex until you're emotionally ready for it is a rational decision, and shouldn't be one based on hangups over your body and fear of God's punishment.

As for young master Dickson, well, if he finds it hard to get over Ryan Seacrest's taunts, I suspect he can always find a sympathetic shoulder to cry on over at Clay Aiken's place. Malicious rumors suggest he's not all that into kissing girls either.


  1. For those keeping score at home:

    I kissed a girl last night...clearly I'm going to hell.

  2. I watched that, it was hilarious. His dad seemed like the major influence there, it was a bit pathetic how attached he still is.

  3. I would posit that he is, in fact, treating women like sexual objects much more than the average person, because in his mind women are such sexual objects that he can't even touch one without it being all about teh secks. I would guess that he spends much more time obsessing about the fact that he's NOT making out with girls than he would think about it if he actually were kissing some.

    Really, when you make it such a part of your identity that it's your tagline for American Idol, you're spending far too much time and energy on it.

  4. The whole "key to her heart" thing sounds sweet in one of those corny Valentine's day-present sort of ways, but the way his father holds the keys and hands them out on the wedding days of the children is very creepy. It seems more like the key to the chastity belt than the key to one's heart.

    Also, this guy asked his father to help him not get laid. Buying a T-shirt that says "I asked my father to help me not get laid" would pretty much do the trick.

  5. Good point Carlie. That's seems to be the mindset in conservative Muslim societies, which would explain why countries like Saudi Arabia do not permit women to associate with men who are not their husbands and family members. These societies seem incapable of conceiving of the possibility that men and women can interact in public, be it in the classroom, the workplace, or a shopping mall, without there being a sexual subtext to it.

  6. @Matt D,

    Is there anything worse than hell, cause what I did last night weren't just kissin'.

  7. Hell is "one size fits all" - premarital sex, genocide, polycotton...

  8. There's something in the bible about not worshipping false idols anyway. And he wants to be an American Idol. Therefore, he's going to heck anyway.

  9. I think people should leave him alone. If he wants to have his first kiss on his wedding day, than it's fine. Everybody has their own way to respect themselves and others. He didn't say his way was the best way, did he?


PLEASE NOTE: The Atheist Experience has moved to a new location, and this blog is now closed to comments. To participate in future discussions, please visit

This blog encourages believers who disagree with us to comment. However, anonymous comments are disallowed to weed out cowardly flamers who hide behind anonymity. Commenters will only be banned when they've demonstrated they're nothing more than trolls whose behavior is intentionally offensive to the blog's readership.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.